Ask the Dietitian – Cardio or Weights?
This week’s question for the dietitian is a common one we get here at Feed the Soul.
I’m trying to lose weight and I only have time for 30 minutes of exercise a day. Since my time is limited, I tend to focus on cardiovascular exercise like walking, but I know that resistance training is important, too. Should I alternate days of cardio and weight training or should I stick to my cardio-only routine?
If you’re trying to lose weight, burning calories is important and cardio exercise will generally burn more calories than weight training. However, the more muscle you have on your body, the more calories your body burns at rest (increasing your metabolism). This means there is a big benefit to weight training if you want to keep weight off over the long term. Not to mention that strong, shapely muscles are just plain nice to have.
To address your time issue and still get in both cardio and weight training, you might want to try interval training. Alternate intensive bursts of cardio with several minutes of strength training or resistance work for the entire 30 minutes of your workout and you’ll find you’re burning plenty of calories and building muscle at the same time. If you need help coming up with an interval routine, consult a trainer at your gym or look for a workout that fits your schedule at Shape, Fitness or Women’s Health.
You might also want to consider fitting in a few strength training exercises throughout your day so that you can focus on cardio at the gym. It’s not as hard as you might think:
- Do pushups, squats and crunches during the commercial breaks of your favorite shows.
- Do biceps curls while you’re on the phone at work.
- Pick a few of your favorite strength exercises to do during your lunch break at work.
You’d be surprised at how much you can get done throughout your day if you focus on doing just one or two exercises at a time.
If you do find that you have some extra time in your schedule, you might also consider taking a Pilates or yoga class once or twice a week. While these classes are not as focused on building muscle as dedicated strength training is, practicing Pilates or yoga regularly can also improve your overall strength, balance and flexibility.
"Eat well. Live well. Be well."

